Search results

Fair enough, I guess we shall see if my confidence is misplaced! It often is!

Yeah it's weird to me that they have quasi-ethnic diversity (of a slightly forced kind*) but don't really seem, in the art we've seen, to have much in the way of the unexpected class/species-wise. Now, with an art piece for EVERY single class AND every single subclass, so 60 pieces (in theory)...

I'm confident in the content, but you wanna bet internet somethings on it? I'm happy to. I'm very confident that it will broadly unchanged save for the removal of rough edges/stuff that doesn't fit with modernity, and very specifically that they won't have leaned into the "decline" or...

I guess we're thinking of different kinds of fan. WotC, like TSR before them, made repeated efforts to make Greyhawk happen - not just with trying to make it the default setting 3.XE. I'm too lazy to dig up my old post where I went through them in extreme detail. I think the issue that limits...

I can, and I can absolutely give specific examples, because I remember a lot of times WotC absolutely did exactly what people on here were saying - for example, people thought the 2024 Thief thing where they only got SA once per round (rather than per turn) was dumb as hell here, and WotC...

So the bottom one is a halfling, right? Because she has nowt in common with the rest - she just looks like a pretty woman who is very small - she doesn't even have the same distinctive ears as the rest. Whereas the first and third are freakish and hideous but definitely have a specific look -...

Nah mate. I can't even think of a time it was. But maybe it's all in our own perceptions?

This is the best sell I've seen for Greyhawk for a long time, I must say. I think if they leant into a more Dark Souls-ish "everything in decline" (as you put it) or at least generally somewhat morally ambiguous mercenary-centric updated take, they could do something interesting. My contention...

Yeah I'm hoping they have two Ultraloths here. I do love a good Ultraloth. They're one of the more fun evil lower planes types.

I know you always say this, but there's never been a time when the feedback here was significantly at odds with the feedback WotC said they received. What frequently has happened is WotC simply hasn't talked about the feedback they received, so we just don't know, but at odds? Nah. Whether they...

I don't really buy "It's bad and deeply uninspiring on purpose, they want you to do better!" when they put in a massive poster map. The poster map shows the D&D team think it's super-cool and exciting, not boring and generic.

Do they? I've seen so little art of gnomes in 5E that I can even think of that I wouldn't have thought of that.

Re: the cover, I think the appropriate response is: It's a D&D PHB cover. I have never liked a D&D PHB cover in an artistic/aesthetic sense. I have always liked D&D despite a lot of mediocre or even truly terrible or actively off-putting cover art - very different to say, Shadowrun, which...

In general this all seems fine/good - the new monsters seem sensible. I didn't expect CR to go - I do hope they've improved encounter-design recommendations a great deal in the DMG, particularly focusing on moving away from the 6-8 encounters/adventuring day thing (and I do mean moving away, not...

I'm not sure I agree. In fact, I would definitely say that at a glance, I would have called this for a gnome, not a halfling, and only maybe revised that if I looked carefully and noticed the lack of pointed ears. It doesn't have any features I'd classically associate with being a halfling. The...

Let us pray, pray, pray that they in now way whatsoever resemble the godawful UA we saw. Those were bad on just about every level, but to be fair to WotC, that's probably exactly the feedback they got, given they didn't seem very well-received. How much they've changed and how will be a very...

I don't buy it. It's just another attempt to make Greyhawk happen. If it was really just "Well we wanted an middle-of-the-road setting" there wouldn't a poster map and so on.

I'm not at all surprised, just disappointed. As I've pointed out in previous threads many times, WotC has consistently shown, for the whole time they've owned the D&D property, an irrational and fannish obsession with Greyhawk, and have repeatedly tried to "make it happen". To be fair, TSR did...

This is an easy one. The people in charge of D&D at WotC have an irrational and bizarre love of Greyhawk and will try and "make Greyhawk happen" at absolutely all costs. They've done it a bunch of times. It always fails, because Greyhawk is a very profoundly boring and dated setting, and...

Mostly I'd say "small experimental games" for these, but there is a sort of subset where the win condition thing is quite a major part, when it's generally absent from other indie and mainstream RPGs, and that honestly strikes me as something different and worthy of a name. There's a guy on...