The VOIDRUNNER'S CODEX is coming! Explore new worlds, fight oppressive empires, fend off fearsome aliens, and wield deadly psionics with this comprehensive boxed set expansion for 5E and A5E!
I mean, there's a whole lot of things BG3 does very, very well, which means people are going to like it for a lot of different reasons.
Speaking for myself, I can say the combat mechanics are a fairly significant part of why I like it. I can also say the city of Baldur's Gate itself was a...
Kinda wondering if Larian's decision to move on from Baldur's Gate was the final straw here. On top of everything else, of course (OGL, Pinkertons, etc.).
I will always push back against caster supremacy, and doubly so against proposals that EXACERBATE that problem. The disrespect was 100% intentional. Cope.
To be fair, certain martials can still use that 1 attack from HM Haste effectively. Hunter Rangers with Volley/Whirlwind (which counts as one attack in BG3 rather than a whole action and thus does not suck), Tiger Barbarians, Paladins with smites to use, mainly. Or anyone with Arrows of Many...
Limits the extra action to 1 attack a la 5e Haste, but still allows 2 spells a round.
So turning Haste into a still-busted 3.0 version of the spell for casters, but making it as weak for martials as it is in 5e.
My comparison is basically:
Original cut Godfather 3: Stupid AND very boring.
Godfather Coda: Still stupid, but not quite as boring.
But most of the stuff that made you roll your eyes in Godfather 3 before is still there in Coda, other than having slightly less of Sofia Coppola's performance.
I'm just glad the director's cut that came out not too long ago dropped the 3 off the title and renamed it Coda. Now we don't have to pretend it's an integral part of the story with the first two.
(Coincidentally, Coda is at least a much better paced experience than the original cut, though...